Neuroleptics in the treatment of aggressive challenging behaviour for people with intellectual disabilities: A randomised controlled trial (NACHBID)

Tyrer, P., Oliver-Africano, P., Romeo, R., Knapp, M., Dickens, S., Bouras, N., Ahmed, Z., Cooray, S., Deb, S., Murphy, D., Hare, M., Meade, M., Reece, B., Kramo, K., Bhaumik, S., Harley, D., Regan, A., Thomas, D., Rao, B., Karatela, S., Lenotre, L., Watson, J., Soni, A., Crawford, M., Eliahoo, J. and North, B. (2009) Neuroleptics in the treatment of aggressive challenging behaviour for people with intellectual disabilities: A randomised controlled trial (NACHBID). Health Technology Assessment, 13 21: i-73. doi:10.3310/hta13210

Attached Files (Some files may be inaccessible until you login with your UQ eSpace credentials)
Name Description MIMEType Size Downloads
UQ180301_OA.pdf Full text (open access) application/pdf 707.45KB 0

Author Tyrer, P.
Oliver-Africano, P.
Romeo, R.
Knapp, M.
Dickens, S.
Bouras, N.
Ahmed, Z.
Cooray, S.
Deb, S.
Murphy, D.
Hare, M.
Meade, M.
Reece, B.
Kramo, K.
Bhaumik, S.
Harley, D.
Regan, A.
Thomas, D.
Rao, B.
Karatela, S.
Lenotre, L.
Watson, J.
Soni, A.
Crawford, M.
Eliahoo, J.
North, B.
Title Neuroleptics in the treatment of aggressive challenging behaviour for people with intellectual disabilities: A randomised controlled trial (NACHBID)
Journal name Health Technology Assessment   Check publisher's open access policy
ISSN 1366-5278
2046-4924
Publication date 2009-04-01
Year available 2009
Sub-type Article (original research)
DOI 10.3310/hta13210
Open Access Status File (Publisher version)
Volume 13
Issue 21
Start page i
End page 73
Total pages 92
Place of publication Southampton, United Kingdom
Publisher National Coordinating Centre for Health Technology Assessment
Language eng
Subject 2719 Health Policy
Abstract Objective(s): To assess the effects and cost-effectiveness of haloperidol, risperidone and placebo on aggressive challenging behaviour in adults with intellectual disability.
Formatted abstract
Objective(s): To assess the effects and costeffectiveness of haloperidol, risperidone and placebo on aggressive challenging behaviour in adults with intellectual disability.

Design: A double-blind randomised controlled trial of two drugs and placebo administered in flexible dosage, with full, independent assessments of aggressive and aberrant behaviour, global improvement, carer burden, quality of life and adverse drug effects at baseline, 4, 12 and 26 weeks, and comparison of total care costs in the 6 months before and after randomisation. At 12 weeks, patients were given the option of leaving the trial or continuing until 26 weeks. Assessments of observed aggression were also carried out with key workers at weekly intervals throughout the trial.

Setting: Patients were recruited from all those being treated by intellectual disability services in eight sites in England, one in Wales and one in Queensland, Australia.

Participants: Patients from all severity levels of intellectual disability; recruitment was extended to include those who may have been treated with neuroleptic drugs in the past.

Exclusion criteria: Treatment with depot neuroleptics/another form of injected neuroleptic medication within the last 3 months; continuous oral neuroleptic medication within the last week; those under a section of the Mental Health Act 1983 or Queensland Mental Health Act 2000.

Interventions: Randomisation to treatment with haloperidol (a typical neuroleptic drug), risperidone (an atypical neuroleptic drug) or placebo using a permuted blocks procedure.

Dosages were: haloperidol 1.25–5.0 mg daily; risperidone 0.5–2.0 mg daily.

Main outcome measures: Primary: reduction in aggressive episodes between baseline and 4 weeks using Modified Overt Aggression Scale.

Secondary: Aberrant Behaviour Checklist; Uplift/Burden Scale; 40-item Quality of Life Questionnaire; Udvalg for Kliniske Undersøgelser scale; Clinical Global Impressions scale. Economic costs recorded using a modified version of Client Service Receipt Inventory for 6 months before and after randomisation.

Results: There were considerable difficulties in recruitment because of ethical and consent doubts.  Twenty-two clinicians recruited a total of 86 patients. Mean daily  dosages were 1.07 mg rising to 1.78 mg for risperidone and 2.54 mg rising to 2.94 mg for haloperidol. Aggression declined dramatically with all three treatments by 4 weeks, with placebo showing the greatest reduction (79%, versus 57% for combined drugs) (p = 0.06). Placebo-treated patients showed no evidence of inferior response in comparison to patients receiving neuroleptic drugs. An additional study found that clinicians who had not participated in clinical trials before were less likely to recruit. Mean total cost of accommodation, services, informal care and treatment over the 6 months of the trial was £16,336 for placebo, £17,626 for haloperidol and £18,954 for risperidone.

Conclusions: There were no significant important benefits conferred by treatment with risperidone or haloperidol, and treatment with these drugs was not cost-effective. While neuroleptic drugs may be of value in the treatment of aggressive behaviour in some patients with intellectual disability, the underlying pathology needs to be evaluated before these are given. The specific diagnostic indications for such treatment require further investigation. Prescription of low doses of neuroleptic drugs in intellectual disability on the grounds of greater responsiveness and greater liability to adverse effects also needs to be re-examined.
Keyword Health Care Sciences & Services
Health Care Sciences & Services
HEALTH CARE SCIENCES & SERVICES
Q-Index Code C1
Q-Index Status Provisional Code
Institutional Status UQ

Document type: Journal Article
Sub-type: Article (original research)
Collection: School of Public Health Publications
 
Versions
Version Filter Type
Citation counts: TR Web of Science Citation Count  Cited 20 times in Thomson Reuters Web of Science Article | Citations
Scopus Citation Count Cited 24 times in Scopus Article | Citations
Google Scholar Search Google Scholar
Created: Thu, 03 Sep 2009, 17:46:04 EST by Mr Andrew Martlew on behalf of Queensland Centre for Intellectual and Developmental Disability