Environmentalism versus constitutionalism: A contest without winners

Ratnapala, Suri (2007) Environmentalism versus constitutionalism: A contest without winners. Resource Management Theory and Practice, 3 110-164.

Author Ratnapala, Suri
Title Environmentalism versus constitutionalism: A contest without winners
Journal name Resource Management Theory and Practice
ISSN 1177-1003
Publication date 2007-01-01
Sub-type Article (original research)
Volume 3
Start page 110
End page 164
Total pages 55
Place of publication Auckland, New Zealand
Publisher Resource Management Law Association of New Zealand
Language eng
Subject 1801 Law
Abstract The New Zealand Resource Management Act imposes a system for micro-managing the environment. The Act is typical of current state approaches to environmental protection that places heavy reliance on command and control systems in preference to market based systems. Such laws impact heavily on property rights and due process and generally undermine the rule of law by creating centres of arbitrary authority. They also prevent the harnessing of widely dispersed knowledge that is vital to the determination of the costs and benefits of conservation and the development of realistic policy. These measures have been justified on the basis of the ‘precautionary principle’ and the concept of sustainable development and they are supported by claims of scientific consensus about major environmental issues such as climate change. The essay questions this consensus and argues that the precautionary principle and sustainable development are vacuous but dangerous doctrines. The apocalyptic and utopian visions of conservation are challenged and an evolutionary conceptualisation of the environment is proposed. The essay discusses the importance of property rights and compensation for takings as means of advancing legitimate environmental goals and argues that the New Zealand Resource Management Act is a deeply flawed model that imposes serious economic and constitutional costs that ultimately will weaken society’s capacity to achieve those goals.
Keyword Environmental protection
Constitutional law
Environmental law
Resource Management Act (NZ)
New Zealand Constitution
Property rights
Due process
Precautionary principle
Q-Index Code CX
Q-Index Status Provisional Code
Institutional Status UQ
Additional Notes The University of Queensland Legal Research series. TC Beirne School of Law Research Paper No. 09-17

Document type: Journal Article
Sub-type: Article (original research)
Collections: Excellence in Research Australia (ERA) - Collection
ERA 2012 Admin Only
TC Beirne School of Law Publications
Version Filter Type
Citation counts: Google Scholar Search Google Scholar
Created: Thu, 21 May 2009, 00:29:21 EST by Ms Lynette Adams on behalf of Faculty of Business, Economics & Law