Analysis of interactional strategies and reciprocal positions leading to a successful discussion in French

Julien Chartier (2011). Analysis of interactional strategies and reciprocal positions leading to a successful discussion in French PhD Thesis, School of Languages and Comp Cultural Studies, The University of Queensland.

Attached Files (Some files may be inaccessible until you login with your UQ eSpace credentials)
Name Description MIMEType Size Downloads
s41321418_phd_40pageEnglishsummary.pdf PhD thesis application/pdf 1.62MB 14
s41321418_phd_Thesissubmissionform.pdf 40 page English summary of the thesis application/pdf 1.90MB 9
s41321418_phd_abstract.pdf Abstracts application/pdf 69.87KB 10
s41321418_phd_finalthesis.pdf Thesis submission form application/pdf 2.76MB 26
Author Julien Chartier
Thesis Title Analysis of interactional strategies and reciprocal positions leading to a successful discussion in French
School, Centre or Institute School of Languages and Comp Cultural Studies
Institution The University of Queensland
Publication date 2011-11-10
Thesis type PhD Thesis
Total pages 274
Total black and white pages 274
Language eng
Subjects 20 Language, Communication and Culture
Abstract/Summary What constitutes successful participation in discussion in French? The project combines qualitative and quantitative methods to determine what behaviours constitute successful participation in French debate among learners of French. After group discussions on polemical topics among advanced learners of the language were recorded in Australia, a group of French age-peers judged the exchanges on their relative success and on aspects of interactional behaviour including the extent to which participants advanced debate, dominated and/or supported each other. These aspects were identified prior to the evaluation through a comparative analysis of definitions of a successful and a failed discussion as provided by the participants. The Francophone assessments of the recordings were then analysed to determine which of these aspects correlated with the overall success of the exchange. Building on these results, and drawing on the principles of cross-cultural pragmatics, a multidimensional interactionist analysis of the most and least successful exchanges was undertaken to identify interactional strategies contributing to the success or failure of the exchanges. This involved focussing on the various phenomena and behaviour observable in the discussions judged most successful but absent in the least successful discussions, analysing the waveform representations of the audio-recordings to determine the sound atmosphere, analysing non-verbal behaviour, and undertaking a detailed micro-analysis of the transcription of these exchanges. Results showed that advancing debate through advancing and challenging opinions was most likely to lead to the Francophones judging the discussions as successful. The most successful discussions showed participants adopting a wide range of interchangeable interactional positions in which all could successively take the lead in discussion, and consistently questioning and elaborating opinions, thus placing a clear emphasis on the co-construction of ideas. Least successful discussions as seen by the Francophones showed greater concern for facework strategies and followed a stable pattern of opinions being offered in turn but not negotiated, leading to agreement rather than debate. The sound and visual atmosphere of the discussion was also directly connected to the success of the discussion: the non-verbal behaviour analysis showed that participants in successful discussions displayed an increased use of hand gestures and maintained visual contact between the participants while the waveform analysis underlined situations of brouhaha as a recurring component of the most successful discussions. The project departs from previous studies by focusing on discussion in French as a multilayered cultural practice and therefore undertaking a multidimensional analysis to ascertain the elements that correlate with its success or failure. The findings of the project will provide a better understanding of the cultural specificity of different interactional styles, and of the cultural anchoring of interactional strategies contributing to the success or failure of a discussion. It will serve as a potential basis for teaching interactional skills and pragmatic competence in French as a second language.
Keyword cross-cultural pragmatics
intercultural communication
interactional strategies
positioning theory
Additional Notes Pages to be printed in landscape: 97-99, 103-105, 111-112, 114, 123, 132, 145-146, 153-154, 173-174, 178, 182-183, 187-189, 196-198, 205-207, 212-215, 221-225, 239-242

Citation counts: Google Scholar Search Google Scholar
Created: Fri, 16 Dec 2011, 14:17:38 EST by Julien Chartier on behalf of Library - Information Access Service