Dog-assisted Therapy for Older People with Dementia: A Randomised Controlled Trial in Residential Aged Care Facilities

Perkins, Jacqueline R. (2008). Dog-assisted Therapy for Older People with Dementia: A Randomised Controlled Trial in Residential Aged Care Facilities PhD Thesis, School of Veterinary Science, The University of Queensland.

Attached Files (Some files may be inaccessible until you login with your UQ eSpace credentials)
Name Description MIMEType Size Downloads
s31073080_phd_abstract.pdf Thesis abstract application/pdf 15.25KB 3
s31073080_phd_totalthesis.pdf Total thesis application/pdf 1.14MB 11
Author Perkins, Jacqueline R.
Thesis Title Dog-assisted Therapy for Older People with Dementia: A Randomised Controlled Trial in Residential Aged Care Facilities
School, Centre or Institute School of Veterinary Science
Institution The University of Queensland
Publication date 2008-12
Thesis type PhD Thesis
Supervisor Helen Bartlett
Catherine Travers
Judy Seton
Total pages 260
Total colour pages 12
Total black and white pages 248
Subjects 07 Agricultural and Veterinary Sciences
Formatted abstract
Rapid increases in population ageing and the associated rise in the prevalence of dementia have created many challenges for the care of older people with dementia. As the majority of people now living in residential aged care facilities (RACFs) now have dementia, the need to maximise the quality of life for this group is increasingly recognised. While such issues have attracted research and policy attention in recent years, the evidence base for practice in dementia care is still underdeveloped. The need for more effective therapeutic interventions to improve the quality of life for older people with dementia is recognised, particularly those living in RACFs. The use of pets is one example of recent attempts to help create a more home-like environment and dog therapy is available in many facilities. Well designed research to demonstrate whether it actually has a positive impact on residents' quality of life is lacking.

This study is the first reported randomised controlled trial investigating dog therapy for people with dementia. Fifty-five older people with mild to moderate dementia living in three residential aged care facilities in the Greater Brisbane area participated in this study. The goal was to identify whether dog therapy accrued any benefits to residents' well being and compare the benefits, if any, with human-only therapy intervention. The main hypothesis was that dog contact delivered in a small group recreational therapy format would have a beneficial effect on the well being of participants. It was additionally hypothesised that prior and current positive relationships with dogs would be related to improved outcomes of dog therapy and support a human-animal bond explanation of relationship development with the therapy dog(s).

Participants were randomly assigned into two groups within each facility: The dog therapy group and a human-only therapy group. Session plans were structured according to a recreational therapy format. Three therapy dogs were used (a miniature Poodle, a Staffordshire Terrier and a German Shepherd Dog) with one dog present at any dog therapy session. A before-and-after design was used with concealment of participants at allocation. Mixed methods were used including a panel of seven validated psychometric instruments, an observational measure and a series of four novel questionnaires, dogs for older groups with Alzheimer's (DOGA), developed de novo specifically to investigate the effects of dog therapy on participants within this study.

Measures of mood, quality of life, health and psychosocial functioning, collectively referred to as well-being, detected benefits accruing to dog therapy participants compared with human-only therapy that approached significance (p = .056) with a large effect size (partial eta squared 16.6%). A different measure of mood and apathy showed similar improvement for participants of both therapy types trialed with analyses of a smaller dataset (n = 36) revealing an overall highly significant result (p=.008) and large effect size (partial eta squared = 25.6%) for all participants.

To explore the perceptions of care staff to the dog therapy intervention, a self-complete semi-structured questionnaire was completed by a sample of 21 from two of the study facilities. Content analysis revealed that staff overwhelmingly supported dog therapy with a total of 84 comments about benefits and 22 about risks. Responses were categorised and then linked into emergent themes: a temporal dimension, sense of self and increased opportunities for self expression. The opportunity provided by the therapy dog for accessible caring physical contact for participants was identified as important. General recreational therapy goals such as improved mood, reminiscence and increased levels of conversation were reported by staff to continue beyond interventions. The observed risks were: confusion over dog ownership, subsequent worry about losing the dog after sessions, jealousy over the therapy dog and one participant did not enjoy the small group format.

Participants described their experiences of contact with the therapy dog as "like" above "attached". Personal preference explanations are therefore supported, rather than "attachment", to explain outcomes for participants. This suggests the psychosocial approach has greater relevance here than human-animal bond explanations. Effects of previous dog attachment on outcomes were inconclusive but there was some evidence that participants' relationship with the therapy dog(s) influenced outcomes, though the nature of that relationship has not been clarified.

Recommendations from the study findings are that dog therapy be conducted for people with mild to moderate levels of dementia in groups of 3-11 for a duration of around 10 weeks with sessions for 30 minutes held once or twice weekly and according to a standard format.

Opportunities for participants to touch, hug and interact directly with the therapy dog should be maximised without compromising dog welfare. The findings suggest that respect for the personhood of participants is important to the success of the therapy types trialled, which further supports psychosocial therapies involving contact with people or live animals for use with people with dementia over those that minimise or exclude it.
Keyword Diversional Therapy
Therapy Treatment
alternative therapies
Dementia care
Dementia Of The Alzheimer Type
Animal-assisted Therapy
Aged care facilities
Residential aged care facilities
Leisure Activities
bonding, human-pet
Dogs Canis-familiaris
Geriatric nursing
Geriatric Depression Scale
Depression Treatment
behavioural and psychosocial factors
prosocial behaviour
Intervention Trial
Intervention strategies
Additional Notes Colour pages: 90-93; 99-101; 103; 212-214; 216 Landscape print: 29-32; 227-228

Citation counts: Google Scholar Search Google Scholar
Created: Thu, 17 Jun 2010, 18:41:49 EST by Jacqueline Perkins on behalf of Library - Information Access Service